Would you tell someone you love, to watch because of love, or… uh, something (Ga-Rei Zero)

Hey guys. Been pretty busy lately, trying to steadily pump out posts but after seeing this recentAsk John(thx owen), I remembered I had a post I’ve sitting on since winter, in which I talked about Ga-Rei Zero. Short story is, I dug it.

Well, the holidays got me sick. Not fun. But being bed-ridden was a great excuse to do my first legit series marathon in a very long time. I chose the supernatural action thriller Ga-Rei Zero. There may be minor spoilers, but considering the bulk of the story is laid out within a couple episodes, there’s not a lot to spoil in this series.

Ga Rei Zero: It's not about this. Sort of.

Story

Ga-Rei Zero is the origin story of the Ga-Rei manga, showing the path a young girl named Kagura took to become a powerful exorcist in a world full of demons and government “spiritual defense” organizations. Told mostly in flashback, Zero recounts the love she shared for 3 years with her surrogate sister Yomi.

There’s not much way to talk about this series without talking about the bizarre beginning: The non-traditional structure is a make-or-break point for Zero. By starting somewhere near the end, telling in flashback, then finally joining the two ends, writer Katsuhiko Takayama (also series writer for ef) constructed a horrible ode to inevitability that anime doesn’t deal in often, and some people just aren’t gonna go for. I can think of a live-action parallel: In Scorsese’s Casino, Robert De Niro’s character dies in a firey car bomb in the first couple minutes. The ensuing movie is entirely a flashback, and three hours later you remember: oh, yeah. He dies. Ga-Rei Zero takes an even more desperately depressing approach. Scorsese aimed to shock you with your forgetfulness, but this series constantly twists the knife to remind you what awaits.

Ga Rei Zero: Yumi

On a superficial level of motorcycles, government demon-fighting teams, heroes-turned-bad, and depressive mood, Zero strongly resembles Blassreiter. It has a few key traits that separate it, though: half length, devotion to standard anime-“isms,” superior animation, and more personal themes of love and individual destiny versus Blassreiter’s focus on faith and duty.

Characters

I really wish Kagura were a more interesting character, but in truth that goes for most of the characters of G-RZ. Rather than a complex collection of emotions, they often feel like they’re just a product of the things that happen to them throughout the series — can you honestly say there are many people out there who wouldn’t have taken Yomi’s route, given the absolute emotional and spiritual pummeling she suffers?

That said, their generic qualities might serve to make them more sympathetic (same question applies here), and as the climax approaches, it’s hard not to feel for Kagura and, to a degree, Yomi’s erstwhile fiancé Noriyuki.

Technical

There isn’t a whole lot to say here. Nothing animation-wise, or audio-wise, went over-the-top for execution, but it’s appealing and more than solid the whole time. Character designs and overall style project a Production IG vibe, but maybe that’s just because Kagura = Saaya (Blood+) to some degree in my mind and it colored everything else. Fight scenes are well-directed and there’s no slippage in the high quality over 12 episodes.

Themes

Amidst all the standard anime junk — dead mothers and distant fathers, swordfighters in seifuku (not complaining), a world of improbable science-meets-magic — Zero manages to raise some interesting points. It’s really too bad that it spends a lot of time broadcasting those points through viewer proxies, dramatic monologues, and its lovely Engrishy tagline, “Would you kill someone you love, because of love?” Not that I expect the average anime to stop holding its viewers’ hands, but Ga-Rei Zero teased that it was going to give me lots to chew on, then took that away by outright verbalizing almost all of it.

Ga Rei Zero: Kagura vs. Yomi

While the show really wants us to ponder the question of whether Yomi overcame the Stone’s power or it just granted her true wish, what’s the difference? Either way, love tragically triumphs over greed and revenge, not that it helps anything. In hindsight, it’s kinda like the Haibane Renmei question of intent, except with damnation in place of salvation as the end result.

The Y Word

If you’ve read anything on blogs about Ga-Rei Zero, you’ve probably heard the word yuri tossed around a few times. In fact, ANN’s page lists “yuri” as the only theme. Glad I wasn’t watching it for that, or the other themes of “senseless suffering,” “inevitable tragedy,” and “sweet swordfighting” would have really distracted me.

Ga Rei Zero: yomiXkagura

But you can feel the sisterly love, and it really has to be ramped up for the horrific result to be felt. In the end, out of 4 hours of series there are about 30 seconds worth of anything that could be called yuri. There is one mouth-to-mouth kiss (a sort of Lady and the Tramp thing with Pocky), but that scene is there for a reason: it’s paralleled later, with horribly sad (if slightly overplayed) results.

So don’t watch this for yuri anymore than you’d watch it for guro — there’s enough blood, bathing, and shortness of skirts to cover your perverted needs, but it’s just not that kind of show. You’d have to be pretty depraved to get your jollies from something so damn depressing.

Bottom Line

Ga-Rei Zero caught me with its surprises in the first couple episodes, but after those were over, it continued to entertain and satisfy with good animation, cute girls with swords, and my ultimate anime fanservice, ludicrous tragedy (geez, maybe I am an extremist after all, clearly some people are not up for that and I guess I can’t blame them).

1990s OVAs full of tits, blood and total apocalypse fed my early fandom, and while this isn’t strictly an update to that it does provide the same kinds of thrills with a little more depth, a lot more heart, and a modern edge. Plus, it’s a lot better than Mnemosyne. Take its 12-episode length into account, and it’s hard for me not to recommend Ga-Rei Zero to anyone who likes their anime dark, action-heavy, and depressing.

Fuck these (7) Comments.

  1. coburn says:

    I enjoyed this one too, and it really did suit a being watched in a rush – it makes me think that sometime soon I should hunt down something else to provide a similar dark ‘n swordy short term obsession. Over-verbalising and generic characterisation is about right in terms of its faults, I also thought the whole ‘stick a stone in you that makes you proper evil’ thing was kind of a cop-out after all the build up to Yomi’s bad turn.

  2. Owen S says:

    Can’t blame the anime much for what coburn views as faults.

    Over-verbalising and generic characterisation is about right in terms of its faults, I also thought the whole ’stick a stone in you that makes you proper evil’ thing was kind of a cop-out after all the build up to Yomi’s bad turn.

    The thing with this is that Ga-Rei Zero happens to be like the similarly-named Fate/Zero, after all–it’s meant to be a prequel to a greater body of work with a larger cast of characters and different scope of action. I’m not going to split hairs here and demand that Ga-Rei Zero be awarded the same amount of attention as Fate/Zero (because nothing could ever rival Gen Urobuchi’s writing), but it never really felt lacking to me for those reasons stated, since I watched it with the knowledge that while it could be viewed as a standalone work, there had to be a bigger picture in mind if one wanted to do it justice.

    And it did just that, if you ask me. I like the bits and pieces of narrative it fiddled around with, although the weapons got a bit too goofy and the men far too impotent for my liking, even if that’s a standard features that comes with this blasted sub-genre of girls with guns (swords!?).

    I do think, however, that what this does exceedingly well is hurtle us down towards a known destination while giving us a hell of a ride in the process. I knew nothing good would come out of it all–but I hoped in the process that it would, somehow, and that’s worth the price of admission alone.

  3. Pingback: Shameful Otaku Secret! » Would You Tell Someone You Love, To Watch … « Naruto

  4. TheBigN says:

    It does make me sad that the Ga-Rei manga isn’t as good to me though. :/

  5. Baka-Raptor says:

    I also thought the whole ’stick a stone in you that makes you proper evil’ thing was kind of a cop-out after all the build up to Yomi’s bad turn.

    I’ve read in quite a few reviews that the characters in Ga-Rei Zero lack depth. No, there’s plenty of depth, you’re all just too lazy to look for it. We all know that the stone doesn’t make you evil, it merely draws out your existing evil. The question is why Yomi harbored evil in the first place. Was it losing her boyfriend? Losing her father? Losing her reputation? Those all had very little, if anything, to do with it. It was all Kagura. Why Kagura? I could write a whole post about it, but my point is this: it’s not quite spelled out the way you and several other reviewers would have us believe.

  6. otou-san says:

    @coburn and Baka-Raptor
    I’m somewhere between the two of you on this: Baka-Raptor is right in that the stone doesn’t actually “make you proper evil,” but it’s much more than just a metaphor/story device in that it does focus the evil, and I think what you’re talking about would be a much more interesting topic without the stone.

    You’re right about it being Kagura, but I disagree that it’s not spelled out. I liked GRZ a lot, but I would have liked it a lot more had it treated me like a smarter person. As for being lazy, well, that talk-through-everything method of storytelling encourages laziness.

    @owen
    Frankly, I think it’s an apologist cop-out to say that something is better appreciated as part of a whole work. Especially considering there is no Ga-Rei anime, Zero needs to stand on its own. Besides, I don’t think a lack of feeling “complete” in vision or story was one of its faults.

    I do think, however, that what this does exceedingly well is hurtle us down towards a known destination while giving us a hell of a ride in the process. I knew nothing good would come out of it all–but I hoped in the process that it would, somehow, and that’s worth the price of admission alone.

    Agreed x1000. I’ve seen very few stories do it like that at all, and fewer do it so well. It’s kind of cruel to the viewer, but I like it that way.

    @TheBigN
    I’ve heard that before from others as well. I would say that helps invalidate Owen’s point about the whole body of work, but I don’t really think it’s a relevant point to begin with. At any rate, kinda sad, but at least the Ga-Rei oeuvre gives us a few very good episodes of prequel anime.

  7. god you guys like this hoe cus she looks good.